The Pittsburgh Steelers' preseason opener against the Green Bay Packers was a showcase of talent and a reminder of the challenges that lie ahead. While the final score favored the Steelers, 28-9, the game revealed some intriguing winners and losers, offering a glimpse into the team's potential for the upcoming season.
Winners
Asante Samuel Jr.: The Cornerback with Clamps
Asante Samuel Jr. dominated the field with his exceptional ball skills. His ability to disrupt passes and get his head in the game is a testament to his potential as a key defensive player. Samuel's performance suggests he could be more than just depth; he might be a game-changer with a unique role in the team's sub-packages.
What makes this particularly fascinating is the context. Samuel has taken advantage of an injury to Joey Porter Jr., showcasing the depth and competitiveness of the Steelers' roster. It's a reminder that every player must bring their A-game, as opportunities can arise from unexpected circumstances.
Germie Bernard: The Gamer
Germie Bernard came alive under the stadium lights, showcasing his zone coverage skills and reliable hands. His strength and elusiveness were on full display, breaking tackles and creating yards after catch (YAC). Bernard's performance suggests he's a true gamer, someone who rises to the occasion when it matters most.
In my opinion, Bernard's ability to adapt and excel in game situations is a valuable asset. It's a quality that can make a significant impact on the team's success, especially in clutch moments.
Will Howard: A Promising Quarterback Debut
Will Howard's first in-stadium action since 2025 was a success. His accuracy and touch on layered throws, especially in the two-minute drill, were impressive. Howard's ability to meet key moments, like completing passes on fourth down, showcases his potential as a reliable quarterback.
One thing that immediately stands out is Howard's composure under pressure. His ability to climb into the pocket and connect with his receivers is a sign of a mature and confident player. It will be interesting to see how he develops further and competes for a starting role.
Lew Nichols: Hard-Charging Running Back
Lew Nichols continued his hard-charging style of play, pushing the pile and gaining yards after contact. His ability to keep his legs moving, even in tight situations, is a valuable asset. Nichols' performance suggests he could be a reliable option for the Steelers' running game.
What many people don't realize is that Nichols' running style is a reflection of his understanding of the game. Bouncing runs wide and converting on fourth downs are strategic moves, and his overall performance showcases a smart and versatile running back.
The Receiving Duo: Ben Skowronek and Robert Tonyan
Will Howard's success was amplified by the key catches of Ben Skowronek and Robert Tonyan. Skowronek's ability to convert on third and fourth downs, and Tonyan's availability in the two-minute drill, highlight their potential as reliable targets.
From my perspective, the chemistry between Howard and this receiving duo is a promising sign. It suggests a strong connection and understanding, which can be a game-changer in critical situations. The Steelers' offense could benefit greatly from this emerging partnership.
Yahya Black and Gabiel Rubio: Solid Nose Tackles
The nose tackle duo of Yahya Black and Gabiel Rubio played a crucial role in solidifying the Steelers' run defense. Their ability to two-gap and key the runner wide, as well as their performance in coverage, showcases their versatility and potential as impact players.
A detail that I find especially interesting is Black's first snap in the 3-4 defense. It suggests a strategic move by the coaching staff, utilizing Black's skills in a specific defensive package. This kind of strategic deployment can be a game-changer, especially against certain opponents.
Kaden Wetjen: Return Specialist and Receiver
Kaden Wetjen had an impressive performance, showcasing his talent as a return specialist and receiver. His ability to break tackles and create space on returns, as well as his explosive catch and run, highlight his potential as a game-breaking player.
What this really suggests is that Wetjen could be a valuable asset in multiple facets of the game. His versatility as a returner and receiver could be a significant advantage for the Steelers, especially in creating mismatches and big play opportunities.
Drew Allar: Shining in the Spotlight
Drew Allar followed Howard's act with a strong performance of his own. His accuracy and timing, especially on the 74-yard catch and run to Wetjen, showcase his potential as a reliable quarterback. Allar's ability to finish drives with touchdowns, both through the air and on the ground, is a promising sign.
In my opinion, Allar's performance is a testament to the depth and talent of the Steelers' quarterback room. With two young quarterbacks shining in their first preseason game, the competition and development within the position group could be a key strength for the team.
Daylen Everette: A Quietly Impressive Rookie
Daylen Everette's performance might not have been as loud as some of his teammates, but his ability to hold his own in coverage and fit the run is a sign of his potential. Everette's performance, along with the rest of the rookie class, showcases the depth and talent the Steelers have brought in through the draft.
The rookie class' impressive showing is a testament to the team's scouting and development processes. It's a reminder that while veteran talent is crucial, a strong foundation of young, talented players can be a significant advantage in the long run.
Jamin Davis: A Positive Performance
Jamin Davis, who has been miscast as an outside linebacker, defended the boot game well, picking up two sacks. His performance suggests he could be a valuable asset in specific defensive packages, showcasing his pass rush abilities.
What this really suggests is that Davis' role might need to be redefined. While he might not fit the traditional outside linebacker mold, his ability to impact the game in specific situations could be a strategic advantage for the Steelers' defense.
Losers
Discipline and Penalties: A Sloppy Performance
The Steelers' performance was marred by penalties, with 11 for 143 yards. This lack of discipline is a concern, especially coming into the game with a warning about potential sloppiness. The penalties came from all sides, highlighting a need for improvement across the board.
What this really suggests is a lack of focus and attention to detail. While preseason games can be messy, the Steelers' performance is a reminder that discipline and execution are crucial, especially in a league where every play matters.
Kaleb Johnson: Losing Ground
Kaleb Johnson's lack of offensive snaps and touches is a concern. His performance, or lack thereof, suggests he might not be a good fit in Mike McCarthy's scheme. Johnson's limited involvement could be a sign that he's losing ground in the competition for a roster spot.
In my opinion, Johnson's situation is a reminder of the competitive nature of the NFL. With a clean slate, he hasn't been able to make a strong case for himself, and his future with the team is uncertain.
Troy Fautanu: Rust and Inconsistency
Troy Fautanu's performance was inconsistent, allowing pressure and picking up penalties. While there are mitigating circumstances, such as Mason Rudolph not climbing the pocket and Lew Nichols' run bounce, Fautanu's performance suggests he might be knocking off rust after shifting positions.
What this really suggests is that Fautanu needs more time to adjust and find his rhythm. While he might not be at his best right now, his potential and talent are still there. It's a matter of consistency and finding his groove again.
Deeper Analysis
The Steelers' preseason opener was a mixed bag, showcasing both promising talent and areas that need improvement. While the winners and losers are a snapshot of the game, the true test will come in the regular season. The team's ability to address discipline issues, find consistency, and develop young talent will be crucial in determining their success.
Conclusion
The Steelers' preseason journey has begun, and while there are challenges ahead, the team has shown flashes of potential. The winners and losers of this game are a starting point, a snapshot of the team's current state. As the season progresses, the true test will be in how the Steelers adapt, improve, and ultimately perform on the biggest stage.
